|
|
||||||||

* Department of Kinesiology and Health Studies, Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, Louisiana 70402; and
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Womens Health Research Institute of Amarillo, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, Amarillo, Texas 79106
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
60 min) exercise, a reduction in leptin concentrations reported from 1 to 3 hr of running or cycling has been attributed to diurnal reduction in circulating leptin, independent of exercise. Exercise that produces a sufficient energy imbalance (kilocalorie intake versus kilocalorie expenditure) suppresses 24-hr mean and amplitude of the diurnal rhythm of leptin in women. Suppression of leptin concentrations may be counterbalanced by feeding and may explain consistent reports of reductions in leptin concentrations following extreme bouts of exercise such as marathons or ultramarathons. In addition, leptin concentrations are reduced 48 hr after long-term aerobic exercise and long-term resistance exercise is associated with delayed leptin reduction 9 hr postexercise. Training studies have documented that short-term exercise training (
12 weeks) does not affect leptin levels, with the exception of patients with type 2 diabetes. Exercise training protocols that result in reduced fat mass will lower leptin concentrations, thus, most investigators have reported leptin concentrations after accounting for fat loss. There are disparate findings concerning long-term (>12 weeks) training studies, with a number of studies finding no effect of training on leptin concentrations other than effects induced by fat loss, and other studies finding reductions in leptin concentrations after accounting for fat loss. Exercise training-induced reductions in leptin levels have been attributed to alterations in energy balance, improvements in insulin sensitivity, alterations in lipid metabolism, and unknown factors. Hormone replacement does not seem to affect leptin adaptations to training. Patients with type 2 diabetes show delayed effects of short-term resistance exercise on leptin concentrations, reduced leptin levels with long-term training, and appear to be more sensitive to training-induced leptin adaptations than other populations.
Key Words: exercise leptin endocrinology human
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Leptin as a Regulator of Energy Balance |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Leptin is regulated by the status of fat storage, with larger adipocytes containing more leptin than smaller ones in the same individual (9). Nutrition-related control of leptin has been suggested to be partially regulated by insulin. It has been demonstrated that leptin expression occurs after elevation of insulin in response to feeding (10), and a decline in leptin levels follows reduction in insulin during fasting (11). Some early studies reported no acute effect of eating on leptin concentrations, but later studies that controlled for fasting demonstrated that meals and insulin acutely affect leptin concentrations (12). Other hormones associated with the regulation of leptin that are altered by exercise include glucocorticoids, growth hormone, and catecholamines (13, 14). Growth hormone and cortisol have been shown to promote leptin production (15, 16), whereas catecholamines inhibit leptin production (17, 18).
| Leptin as a Regulator of Reproductive Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Effects of Exercise on Leptin |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acute Exercise and Leptin |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fisher et al. (12) administered a standardized meal to subjects and observed increases in leptin during 41 min of cycling at 50% of the cycling intensity of VO2max.This was followed by a reduction in leptin concentrations during recovery that increased to control values after 2 hr. Cortisol and epinephrine concentrations rose sharply during exercise, and epinephrine declined quickly after the exercise. Cortisol stimulates leptin expression, whereas epinephrine and norepinephrine inhibit leptin expression. It was hypothesized that large increases in cortisol concentrations would stimulate increases in leptin levels, but only a weak relationship between leptin and cortisol was found. However, the nutrient factors, glucose, insulin, and glucose x insulin, explained 86% of the variance in final leptin levels. The authors reported normalized leptin concentrations (using serum protein content) for plasma volume shifts and concluded that the short-term exercise-related changes are due to alterations in hemoconcentration rather than to leptin mass.
We have demonstrated that 30 min of exercise at 80% of VO2max is associated with reduced leptin concentrations in postmenopausal females regardless of whether they are on or off hormone replacement therapy (HRT), but the reductions were due to the circadian rhythms of leptin as determined from control trial samples from the same subjects (14). Cortisol and growth hormone, both hormones that affect leptin concentrations, increased in these females in response to exercise (29, 34). It is possible that under certain exercise conditions, hormones that stimulate leptin expression (e.g., cortisol) are countered by hormones that inhibit leptin secretion (e.g., epinephrine), such that no alteration from these regulators is evident.
Weltman et al. (39) reported that 30 min of exercise at, above, and below lactate threshold, an index of accelerated metabolism and exercise intensity, did not alter leptin concentrations in young males during exercise or recovery (3.5 hr postexercise) compared with control values. In this study, exercise intensity was not a factor in affecting leptin responses in young men.
We recently reported significant increases in leptin responses to a graded exercise test to exhaustion in young adolescent (1416 years) runners over the course of a short track season (32). The increases in the study may have been due to hemoconcentration, which would have presented higher concentrations of leptin to the leptin receptors.
Thus, short-term (<60 min) exercise studies suggest that leptin production is not acutely effected by short-term exercise, regardless of exercise intensity, in healthy males and females. Reported reductions or increases can be attributed to circadian rhythms or hemoconcentration. It remains to be determined how hormones and metabolites that appear to stimulate (e.g., cortisol, insulin, and glucose) or inhibit (e.g., epinephrine and norepinephrine) leptin work together to prevent decline under some conditions but not in other conditions (12). Further work is also required to determine whether acute increases produced by hemoconcentration produce any effect on tissues. The absence of any reduction in leptin reported in short-term exercise study may be due to the limited energy expenditure of these exercise bouts or the protocol of these studies that excluded prolonged post exercise blood sampling (
4 hr postexercise). As will be shown in the next section, when blood samples are collected 48 hr following long-term exercise, reductions in leptin are found.
Long-Term (
60 min) Exercise.
As for short-term exercise, long-term exercise studies have typically revealed no change or a decline in leptin following exercise. Racette et al. (40) measured arteriovenous differences in leptin concentrations from abdominal adipose tissue during 60 min of cycle ergometry exercise, and reported no change in leptin. Samples were not collected during recovery. Torjman et al. (41) measured leptin concentrations following 60 min of treadmill exercise at 50% of VO2max. After leptin concentrations were corrected for hemoconcentration, they found no effect on leptin concentrations during a 4-hr recovery period. Trained males completing 60 min of running at approximately 70% of VO2max showed leptin concentrations that were significantly lower 48 hr after the exercise compared with before, immediately after, and 24 hr after the exercise (42). The leptin responses did not appear to be related to changes in insulin or glucose concentrations. Blood samples were also collected from the same subjects after a short-term maximal exercise test, and leptin levels did not decline immediately after, or 24 or 48 hr postexercise. Essig et al. (43) reported lower leptin concentrations in trained males 48 hr after but not 0 and 24 hr after two separate exercise tests, an 800- and 1500-kcal treadmill run. The authors speculated that alterations in the leptin stimulators, growth hormone, cortisol, and insulin, as well as the leptin inhibitors testosterone, epinephrine, and norepinephrine, may have affected leptin concentrations. The above studies demonstrate that long-term exercise induces lower leptin concentrations, which is not seen at shorter intervals of recovery. Moreover, it suggests a need for determining the exact point at which delayed leptin reduction occurs. This would require greater sampling frequency than 24 and 48 hr.
Leptin responses to much longer durations of exercise have been examined. One of the first such studies investigated leptin responses of well-trained male runners to a 20-mile treadmill run at an intensity of 70% of VO2max (44). No change in leptin concentrations were found after this extreme bout of exercise. One of the limitations of the study (and other studies to follow) was an infrequent blood sampling protocol. Duclos et al. (38) compared a 4-hr resting trial to a 2-hr run/2-hr resting trial in subjects that consumed a standardized meal 2-hr before exercise to control for fasting. There was a 30% reduction in postexercise resting leptin concentrations. The investigators reported significant inverse correlations between leptin and glycerol as well as free fatty acid levels, but no correlation with cortisol. Tuominen et al. (45) used a 4-hr euglycemic insulin clamp and muscle biopsies to study the effects of 2 hr of treadmill exercise at 75% of VO2max. Exercise reduced leg muscle glycogen by 32% compared with the control clamp trial, and there was a 34% reduction in leptin concentrations. Serum leptin concentrations were reduced by glycogen-depleting exercise and were increased during a hyperinsulinemic clamp. Leptin concentrations correlated directly with serum insulin, cortisol, and triglycerides, and inversely with growth hormone concentrations. The authors concluded that leptin is associated with factors that govern fuel homeostasis.
Leal-Cerro et al. (46) controlled for circadian variations and reported a small reduction in leptin levels in males following a marathon (
26 miles,
2800 kcals) and suggested the actual reduction was greater than measured reduction because hemoconcentration occurred during the marathon. The authors concluded that large changes in energy expenditure may regulate serum leptin concentrations. Karamouzis et al. (47) studied leptin responses following a 25 km sea swim and reported that lower leptin concentrations were associated with an 81% increase in plasma neuropeptide Y which is associated with energy regulation.
Landt et al. (48) reported an 8% reduction in fasting serum leptin concentrations following 2 hr of exercise that included cycling at
75% of VO2max and culminated with five 1-min cycle sprints. The reduction was similar to that of a control group that fasted an identical time period, attributing the exercise related decline to diurnal reduction. The same authors studied pre- and postleptin concentrations that were obtained from runners who completed an ultramarathon, a 101-mile race (average exercise time
35 hr), and demonstrated a 32% decline in leptin. The authors suggested that the large reduction in leptin in the ultramarathoners was due to energy imbalance and that leptin may serve as an important signal of energy imbalance, but only at imbalance extremes.
In a well-controlled study by Hilton and Loucks (49), effects of energy imbalance on leptin, energy intake and expenditure were carefully controlled in sedentary and exercising females, and blood sampling was completed over a 24-hr period to determine whether leptin circadian rhythm was altered. The authors found that low energy availability suppresses the 24-hr mean and amplitude of the diurnal rhythm of leptin; however, exercise had no impact on the diurnal rhythm of leptin in young females except for its effect on energy balance. The authors concluded that the diurnal rhythm of leptin depended on energy or carbohydrate availability. Previous studies have shown that secretion of leptin was inversely proportional to carbohydrate in the diet (50). The authors suggested that there is a reduction threshold of energy availability to change the dynamics of the diurnal rhythm of leptin. These observations suggest that leptin levels may be effected by the total exercise energy expenditure from increased metabolism during exercise as well as during recovery from exercise.
In an energy balance study of young males, van Agel-Leijssen et al. (51) showed that exercise decreased peak and average 24-hr leptin concentrations and that high physical activity in a positive energy-balanced state increases the amplitude of the 24-hr leptin concentrations. However, the negative energy-balance condition did not affect 24-hr leptin concentrations, initially suggesting a gender difference in effects of energy balance when examined with regard to the study of females by Hilton and Loucks (49). However, it should be noted that the there was a 28% negative energy condition in this study of males compared with a 78% reduction in energy intake in the study of females (49), which likely explains the different results.
Koistinen et al. (52) examined the effect of feeding before 3 hr of cycling exercise on leptin concentrations in healthy and type I diabetic males. The authors concluded that exercise may lower circulating leptin concentrations, however, the small reduction may be counterbalanced by feeding or an elevation in cortisol concentrations.
To summarize long-term (
60 min) exercise effects on leptin, a reduction in leptin concentrations reported from 1 to 2 hr of running or cycling has been attributed to diurnal reduction in circulating leptin, independent of exercise. Very long bouts of exercise are more likely to reduce leptin levels, which is probably due to disruption of energy balance. The seminal work by Hilton and Loucks (49) and van Agel-Leijssen et al. (51), which represent the best well-controlled studies for energy balance to date, provide clear evidence of the importance of careful control for energy balance in leptin and exercise studies, and thus impinge on all work in this area. Exercise that produces a sufficient energy imbalance (kilocalorie intake versus kilocalorie expenditure) suppresses 24-hr mean and amplitude of the diurnal rhythm of leptin. Suppression of leptin concentrations may be counterbalanced by feeding. This appears to explain consistent reductions reported in leptin concentration after extreme bouts of exercise such as marathons or ultramarathons. In addition, long-term exercise (
60 min) appears to be associated with reduced leptin concentrations 48 hr after exercise. The mechanism explaining these observations remains to be elucidated.
| Leptin Levels Following Exercise Training |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Dirlewanger et al. (54) measured leptin concentrations after 3 days of no exercise and an isoenergetic diet; exercise (cycling for 30 min at 60% of VO2max) twice daily with the same caloric intake as trial 1; and exercise with dietary intake to cover exercise energy expenditure. There were no changes in leptin concentrations in any of the trials. The authors reported that plasma leptin is unaltered by exercise or small changes in energy balance over short periods of time.
We have studied the effects of a 9-week training program on leptin concentrations of middle-age obese females (55). Training consisted of 34 days of exercise including 2030 min of step aerobics 2 days per week and treadmill running or stationary cycling on additional days. Although cardiorespiratory fitness levels (VO2max) increased after training, there were no changes in fat mass or leptin concentrations.
In a study of adolescent female runners, we measured resting and postmaximal exercise leptin concentrations over the course of a short track season (32). Resting leptin levels were not altered over the 7 weeks, nor were the acute responses to intense exercise.
Halle et al. (56) studied obese males with type 2 diabetes and reported that 1 month of cycling exercise combined with a low-caloric diet resulted in reduced body weight and leptin concentrations. The lower leptin concentrations were associated with reduced cholesterol and triglyceride levels, which was independent of improvements in glucose control. The authors suggested that the relationship between leptin and insulin might be indirectly due to elevated serum triglycerides or fatty acid concentrations. In a 6-week study of 50 sedentary subjects with type 2 diabetes, exercise training (low-intensity walking and cycling) coupled with diet therapy led to lower leptin concentrations independent of changes in body composition, insulin, or glucocorticoids (57). A group on diet therapy without exercise did not show reductions in leptin concentrations.
Long-Term (
12 weeks) Training.
Hickey et al. (20) reported significant reductions in fasting leptin levels in young females (mean age 29 y), but not young males (mean age 27 y) after aerobic exercise training, 4 days/wk, 3045 min/day, for 12 weeks. These leptin reductions in females occurred in the absence of significant alterations in fat mass and results suggest that training has a greater effect on circulating leptin levels in females than in males. A study of obese children (24 girls and 10 boys) reported that after correction for loss of fat mass, leptin concentrations were lowered after 4 months of exercise training (exercise on machines and playing games), but that levels increased in a subsequent 4-month period without physical training (58). The authors speculated that the reduction in leptin concentrations were caused by changes in energy balance.
Middle-age obese males were trained (low to moderate exercise intensity, three to four times per week) and maintained a very low-energy diet for 4 months (59). The authors concluded that leptin concentrations were reduced from aerobic exercise training independent of changes in body fat and plasma insulin concentrations.
Okazaki et al. (60) examined the effects of mild aerobic exercise (50% VO2max) and personal diet counseling for 12 weeks on fat loss and leptin concentrations in obese and nonobese middle-aged sedentary females. The ratio of leptin concentrations to fat mass and to body mass index (BMI) was reduced after the training. The authors suggested that reduced leptin concentrations were probably due to weight reduction and some unknown factor(s).
A large cohort of males with metabolic syndrome (elevated blood lipids, blood pressure, body composition, etc.) were divided into four treatment groups: diet, diet and exercise, exercise, and control (61). Exercise consisted of 60 min of fast walking, jogging, and circuit training three times per week for 1 year. The authors found that both diet and exercise were associated with reduced leptin concentrations beyond the reduction expected from changes in body fat. It was speculated that an improvement in insulin sensitivity could alter leptin concentrations.
Thong et al. (62) examined the independent effects of exercise and weight loss on sedentary males with upper body obesity. Subjects trained for 12 weeks with brisk walking or jogging. Alterations in leptin correlated with changes in both total and subcutaneous adipose tissue. The authors reported that independent of its effect on energy balance, exercise has little effect on leptin secretion.
Males and females with normal body composition were studied in a progressive training protocol of cycling three times per week for 20 weeks (63). Subjects were administered a mild exercise test before and after training in which they cycled for 1012 min at a low intensity (50 W) and progressed to exhaustion. After adjusting for fat mass loss, resting leptin levels were not altered from training, nor were acute leptin responses to the exercise.
Noland et al. (64) measured leptin concentrations in young male and female intercollegiate swimmers across a competitive season. There were no changes in body fat for the males, but there was a reduction for the females with increased training volume. There were no changes in leptin in either group despite the fat loss in females. The authors speculated that no change in leptin with fat loss might be due to training-induced increases in cortisol with intense training.
Kohrt et al. (65) trained postmenopausal females on and off (HRT) first for 2 months with flexibility exercises, then 9 months with walking, jogging, and stair climbing. Regardless of HRT treatment, there were no independent effects of exercise on leptin levels other than the indirect effect of fat loss. In a related nonexercise study, we reported that when body composition is taken into account, estrogen treatment, either in young females receiving estrogen-progestin oral contraceptives or in postmenopausal females who are receiving HRT, does not affect serum leptin concentrations (19).
Thus, short-term exercise training (
12 weeks) does not affect leptin levels, with the exception of patients with type 2 diabetes. Exercise training protocols that result in reduced fat mass will lower leptin concentrations, hence, most investigators have reported leptin concentrations after accounting for fat loss. There are disparate findings concerning long-term (>12 weeks) training studies, with a number of studies finding no effect of training on leptin concentrations other than effects induced by fat loss, and other studies finding reductions in leptin concentrations after accounting for fat loss. Exercise training-induced reductions in leptin levels have been attributed to alterations in energy balance, and glucoregulatory factors including improvements in insulin sensitivity, lipid metabolism, and unknown factors. Despite numerous studies and different protocols, mechanisms responsible for leptin regulation remain to be determined. Hormone replacement does not seem to affect leptin adaptations to training. Patients with type 2 diabetes show a reduction in leptin with long-term training and seem to be more sensitive to training-induced leptin adaptations than other populations.
| Effects of Resistance Exercise on Leptin |
|---|
|
|
|---|
24 hr following lower and upper body resistance exercises, whereas normal subjects did not show the same decline. The authors speculated that a reduction in glucose availability to adipocytes in the diabetic patients may have produced the different response. They also found no effect of chronic resistance training on leptin levels.
In a recent, carefully controlled study, Nindl et al. (67) measured leptin concentrations overnight following 50 total sets of resistance exercise including squats, bench press, leg press, and lat pull-down exercise. Leptin concentrations were lower compared to the control trial at 3 hourly time points, 9, 12, and 13 hr following exercise. Estimated energy expenditure was considerable, averaging 856 kcal. These data, coupled with previous studies (e.g., 42, 43) suggest that exercise with energy cost
800 kcal produces delayed leptin reduction, however it was documented much earlier in this study compared with previous studies. The authors demonstrated the importance of determining leptin concentrations well after completion of the exercise.
Ryan et al. (68) studied effects of 16 weeks of resistance training in obese postmenopausal females with and without weight loss, on plasma leptin and insulin action. The resistance training increased fat-free mass and resting metabolic rate in combined data from both groups. Leptin concentrations declined by 36% in the group that lost weight. Changes in leptin levels were not related to alterations in resting metabolic rate or plasma catecholamines. However, the authors speculated that weight loss in the resistance training/weight loss subjects may have mediated increases in insulin action reported in the study.
| Suggestions for Future Research |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. M. Kristensen, A. B. Johnsen, J. B. Birk, J. N. Nielsen, B. R. Jensen, Y. Hellsten, E. A. Richter, and J. F. P. Wojtaszewski Absence of humoral mediated 5'AMP-activated protein kinase activation in human skeletal muscle and adipose tissue during exercise J. Physiol., December 15, 2007; 585(3): 897 - 909. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. R. Kraemer and V. D. Castracane Exercise and Humoral Mediators of Peripheral Energy Balance: Ghrelin and Adiponectin Experimental Biology and Medicine, February 1, 2007; 232(2): 184 - 194. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. R Christ, M. Zehnder, C. Boesch, R. Trepp, P. E Mullis, P. Diem, and J. Decombaz The effect of increased lipid intake on hormonal responses during aerobic exercise in endurance-trained men. Eur. J. Endocrinol., March 1, 2006; 154(3): 397 - 403. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. A. Emter, S. A. McCune, G. C. Sparagna, M. J. Radin, and R. L. Moore Low-intensity exercise training delays onset of decompensated heart failure in spontaneously hypertensive heart failure rats Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, November 1, 2005; 289(5): H2030 - H2038. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Keller, C. Keller, A. Steensberg, L. E. Robinson, and B. K. Pedersen Leptin gene expression and systemic levels in healthy men: effect of exercise, carbohydrate, interleukin-6, and epinephrine J Appl Physiol, May 1, 2005; 98(5): 1805 - 1812. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J Jurimae and T Jurimae Leptin responses to short term exercise in college level male rowers Br. J. Sports Med., January 1, 2005; 39(1): 6 - 9. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |