|
|
||||||||
Department of Animal Sciences and Division of Nutritional Sciences, 290 Animal Sciences Laboratory, University of Illinois, 1207 West Gregory Drive, Urbana, Illinois 61801
1 To whom requests for reprints should be addressed at Department of Animal Sciences, 290 ASL, 1207 West Gregory Drive, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801. E-mail: dhbaker{at}uiuc.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: iodine toxicity thyroid goiter bromine chick human
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The adult human body contains 15 to 20 mg of I, and roughly 80% is located in the thyroid gland, most in the form of the glycoprotein thyroglobulin, the principal storage form of the thyroid hormones (4). The I present in foods is primarily iodide, but whether the source is iodide (I) or iodate (IO3), that is, in iodized salt or as a dough conditioner in bread making, I absorption from the gut (near 100%) is largely in the form of iodide (4, 5). Urine is the main route of I excretion, although smaller amounts of I are also excreted in feces and sweat (4).
Under normal circumstances, I toxicity is not considered a great problem, except in cases of nuclear fallout radiation exposure and in certain parts of the world where seaweed or kelp is consumed. Seaweed may contain up to 4.5 g I/kg and contribute to daily I intakes as high as 200 mg (6). With I toxicosis following a nuclear accident such as the 1986 Chernobyl accident in Belarus (79), the principal danger is thyroid cancer in children following inhalation or ingestion of radioactive isotopes of I (e.g., 131I). With chronic overconsumption of cold (i.e., nonradioactive) I, the main concern is goiter (6, 1012).
The review that follows will provide background information on I toxicity in animals and humans. Also, our own recent work on amelioration of I toxicity, using an avian model, will be discussed.
| Iodine Toxicity in Animals |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All animal species appear to have a wide margin of safety for excess I consumption. Dietary I levels of 500 to 1000 times the minimal dietary required level are generally well tolerated in rats, pigs, chickens, and ruminant animals (10). Among the species studied, horses seem to be most susceptible to I toxicity. Chronic consumption of diets with high levels of I, for example, kelp consumption by horses, markedly reduces organic binding of I by the thyroid gland, resulting in goiter in the offspring of mares (10).
Studies by Arrington et al. (13, 14), Ammerman et al. (15), Wilgus et al. (16), and Newton and Clawson (17) in rabbits, hamsters, rats, pigs, and chickens suggest that rats, hamsters, pigs, and chickens can tolerate dietary I levels up to 500 mg/kg, but rabbits experience serious mortality in offspring when 250 mg/kg is fed to the dam in late gestation. In 100-kg calves, however, I toxicity signs (coughing, nasal discharge) occurred when supplemented I from calcium iodate reached a dietary level of 50 mg/kg (18). Perdomo et al. (19) fed laying hens I levels ranging from 312 to 5000 mg/kg diet and found that egg laying ceased within a week in hens fed the highest I level; at 312 mg I/kg, egg production was reduced. Within 7 days of discontinuing I feeding, egg production returned to normal, even in hens that had been fed 5000 mg I/kg.
Our recent work in young chicks (20) showed that 600 mg I/kg diet (12 mg/day) was very growth depressing when the I supplement (KI) was provided in a methionine-deficient diet (Fig. 1
). This same level of I, however, was only marginally growth depressing when added to a methionine-adequate diet (Figs. 1
and 2
). Moreover, after 5 to 7 days of ad libitum feeding of these diets, chicks fed dietary I doses at or above 900 mg/kg (600 mg/kg in the methionine-deficient diet) displayed bizarre symptoms. They were observed to fall over and lie relatively motionless for several minutes, after which they seemed to recover and resume their normal standing position, only to fall over once again. Unlike findings in pigs and calves (17, 18), our chicks fed supplemental I levels up to and including 1200 mg I/kg showed no evidence of depressed hemoglobin or hematocrit. The growth depression due to I supplementation resulted in all cases from reduced voluntary food intake. Thus, food efficiency for weight gain (i.e., ratio of gain to food) was not decreased in birds fed supplemental I.
|
|
The I content of both milk and eggs can vary greatly depending on the I content of diets consumed by cows and hens (4, 10). This subject will be addressed later in dealing with both stable and radioactive I ingestion by humans.
| Reversal of Oral Iodine Toxicity in Chicks |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The apparent reversal of all I toxicity symptoms in this 13-day experiment was so dramatic that we decided to do a follow-up study with an even higher level of supplemental I, that is, 1500 mg I/kg (20). This level of dietary I resulted in a severe 35% reduction in growth, and the neurological roll-over syndrome was also severe. Remarkably, 100 mg Br/kg from supplemental NaBr restored both voluntary food intake and growth to normal, and it also prevented the roll-over symptoms (Fig. 3
).
|
There is some evidence that Br may be an essential (ultra) trace element (23, 24). Should this be the case, it is interesting to speculate that the growth depression and neurological roll-over symptoms resulting from excess I ingestion may have been due to an antagonistic effect of excess I on body Br. However, a definitive function for Br per se in the body has not been firmly established. Nonetheless, animal studies in a purified environment (i.e., filtered air, etc.) in which a Br-free purified diet is fed might be fruitful to establish whether Br-deficiency symptoms and Br-supplementation responses would be observed.
It is well established that I in position 5 of the thyronine molecule is required for bioactivity of both T3 and T4. It is also well known that Br can replace I on position 5 of T3 and T4 with full retention of hormone activity (25). The Wolff-Chaikoff effect (26, 27) occurs when excess I is consumed. Thus, when plasma inorganic I exceeds a certain level, organic binding of I by the thyroid gland is inhibited, and this can result in what is popularly referred to as I goiter, a form of hypothyroidism. Whether Br ingestion would ameliorate I goiter is not known.
| Excess Iodine Ingestion by Humans |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Excess Iodine Intake.
The Life Sciences Research Office (LSRO) of the American Societies for Experimental Biology concluded in a 1976 report prepared by Talbot et al. (12) that the incidence of various thyroid disorders, including I goiter, Hashimoto thyroiditis, and Graves disease had increased during the period 1950 to 1976. In 1970, examination of 36,000 Americans showed an overall goiter rate of 3.1%, with a much higher frequency in females than males. Although average I intakes increased during this period (12, 28), the LSRO-commissioned report (12) concluded that a cause-and-effect relationship between thyroid disorders and increased I intake was unwarranted. Whereas Hashimoto thyroiditis and Graves disease are considered autoimmune diseases, I goiter occurs as a direct result of excess I intake. Standard diagnostic tests for I goiter (serum thyroid stimulating hormone [TSH], serum T3 and T4, 123I uptake) often are inconclusive. Thus, the most conclusive test to confirm that an enlarged thyroid gland is due, in fact, to excessive I ingestion is to withdraw the food sources of excess I to see whether the thyroid hyperplasia diminishes and a euthyroid status is achieved.
In Wolffs comprehensive review of iodide goiter (6), four categories were identified: (i) adult I goiter, usually in asthmatic subjects; (ii) I goiter of the newborn due to the mothers being treated with I; (iii) endemic I goiter, primarily observed in Hokkaido, Japan, where large quantities of seaweed are consumed, leading to daily I intakes as high as 200 mg (1300 times the daily I requirement) and a goiter incidence of 6% to 12%; and (iv) Graves disease in patients being treated with KI. The most common form of I goiter is that seen in the north island of Japan, that is, Hokkaido, where seaweed (called kombu) is a dietary staple (11). Plasma inorganic I and urinary I are greatly elevated in this population group.
Well over half of adult I goiter patients have been found to ingest inorganic I for a prolonged period, with daily amounts ranging from 18 mg to 1 g (6). Withdrawal of I in these people usually produces a return to the euthyroid condition, and reintroduction of KI generally causes both goiter and hypothyroidism to reappear within 3 weeks (29, 30). Wolff (6) concluded that the relatively rapid reappearance of goiter after reintroduction of I therapy may be the most conclusive test of whether the goiter was, in fact, caused by excess I ingestion.
A daily I intake of 10 times (i.e., 1.5 mg/day) the minimum daily adult requirement of 0.15 mg/d may cause I goiter in some people (6). Genetic predisposition is likely involved in such cases, but there are also factors other than food I that can influence development of goiter. Some foods contain goitrogenic substances that interfere with thyroid hormone synthesis or release (31). Thus, foods such as cassava (32) and various cruciferous vegetables (e.g., cabbage) contain goitrogens. Also, certain food coloring agents (e.g., erythrosine), medicines (e.g., amiodarone), water purification tablets (33), and cosmetics, as well as skin and dental disinfectants, contain substantial quantities of I (3).
Iodate (IO3) is the form of I often used in iodized salt and as an oxidizing agent in bread making. When consumed (or injected intravenously [IV]), the body readily reduces iodate to iodide. At very high doses of oral IO3 given to experimental animals, hemolysis, nephrotoxicity, hepatic injury, and corrosive effects in the gut have occurred (5). With IV injection of high doses of iodate (above 10 mg/kg body weight) in rats, retinal damage has been seen. In humans, retinal toxicity occurred when KIO3 solution (187 to 470 mg/kg body weight) was ingested by five individuals (34).
Finkelstein and Jacobi (35) studied the suicide records of New York City between 1931 and 1937. They found 18 cases of suicide by I. Although records were incomplete, massive doses of tincture of I were taken orally by all 18 of these suicide victims. Death generally occurred within 48 hrs of I consumption. Prior to coma and eventual death, the patients exhibited vomiting, diarrhea, weakened pulse, and urinary retention.
Radioactive Iodine Exposure.
Radiation exposure above a threshold level can cause either death or modification of living cells. Radiation-induced cancer can occur decades after exposure. Although everyone is exposed to natural radiation from cosmic rays, radon gas in the earth, burning of coal, diagnostic radiology, radiotherapy, and nuclear medicine, the principal focus here is isotopes of I such as 131I, 132I, and 133I (arising from decay of 132Te) resulting from nuclear weapons testing, nuclear accidents (e.g., Chernobyl), and nuclear bombings (Hiroshima and Nagasaki).
Among the 86,572 individuals in the life span study of survivors of the atomic bombings in Japan, 7578 people died of solid tumors during 1950 to 1990, but only 334 of these deaths occurred as a result of radiation exposure (36). As of 1991, about 48,000 persons (56%) in this group were still living, and it was projected that 44% of this population would still be living in 2000.
The 1979 accident at the Three Mile Island reactor in the United States caused serious damage to the reactor core, but a steam explosion did not occur. Moreover, the containment building surrounding the reactor prevented release of all but trace amounts of radioactive gases. The 1986 Chernobyl accident in Belarus lacked the containment feature. Following the 1986 Chernobyl explosion (7, 8, 3640), an intense graphite fire burned for 10 days, and large releases of radioactive materials occurred. Of 600 workers present at the site, 134 received high doses (0.7 to 13.4 Gy) and suffered from radiation sickness; 30 died within the first 3 months. About 200,000 other people received lower doses (0.01 to 0.05 Gy), and their health has been (and continues to be) monitored closely.
Thyroid cancer incidence due to childhood exposure to radioactive I in Belarus and surrounding areas (i.e., up to 500 km from the Chernobyl site) has been estimated at 100-fold compared with the incidence before the Chernobyl accident (9). Both inhalation and consumption of radioactive I in food and beverages have been implicated as causative. Experts have concluded that 131I is the main culprit, but I isotopes with shorter half-lives, as well as 132Te, may have contributed as well (9). Remarkably, apart from thyroid cancer, no increases in other forms of cancer, including leukemia, have occurred in those exposed to ionizing radiation, including the recovery operation workers (9).
The World Health Organization (WHO) expert committee suggested that stable I (as KI) prophylaxis be used to treat neonates and children up to 18 years of age (9). Newborn infants represent a critical risk group. After birth, there is a marked increase in thyroid activity that lasts for only a few days. Thus, radioactive I uptake by the thyroid during this neonatal period is greatly elevated. Also, infants have small thyroid glands, and this means that a higher radiation dose is taken up by the gland per unit dose of radioactive I. A single KI dose providing 12.5 mg I is recommended for infants. Iodine is also actively transported into milk, with as much as 25% of I intake by the mother being secreted into milk (41). Thus, KI prophylaxis for lactating mothers who have been exposed to radioactive I is generally recommended. If known exposure has occurred, however, it would be prudent for the mother to discontinue breast feeding and switch to bottle feeding of uncontaminated milk. The latter, however, is problematic in that much of the thyroid cancer resulting from the Chernobyl accident was thought to have occurred from dairy cows grazing on pasture that was contaminated with radioactive I. Thus, young children received considerable doses of radioactive I from the milk produced by these cows. Howard et al. (42) suggested countermeasures to reduce radioiodine levels in milk from exposed dairy cows.
To receive maximal benefit from stable I for thyroidal blocking, it is important that KI be administered shortly before or as soon after radioactive I exposure as possible (43). The passing radioactive cloud may last for a day, and during this period, a single KI dose should protect the exposed person from inhaled radioactive I (9). Recommended single I dosages (from KI) are 12.5 mg (birth to 1 month), 25 mg (1 month to 3 years), 50 mg (3 to 12 years), and 100 mg (over 12 years of age).
In pregnancy the maternal thyroid gland is stimulated in the first trimester. Hence, women in early pregnancy would take up more radioactive I than nonpregnant women. During later pregnancy, the developing fetus takes up and stores I via placental transfer, which means the fetus could be exposed to considerable radioactive I because of the mothers exposure. Stable I, if carefully administered, can thus protect both the mother and her fetus. In such cases, however, the newborn infant should be carefully monitored for thyroid function.
Remarkably, the risk of radioactive Iinduced thyroid cancer in adults over 40 years of age is extremely low, perhaps approaching zero (9). Stable I prophylaxis is thus not recommended for persons in this age group, unless very high doses of I radiation (5 Gy or higher) are experienced. The low probability of radioactive Iinduced thyroid cancer in adults likely explains why physicians often use 131I therapy to ablate the thyroid gland in patients with Graves disease.
Bromine Use for Radioactive Iodine Exposure.
Because oral Br administration as NaBr was so effective in reversing I toxicity in growing chickens and because efficacy was likely due to blockage of I uptake by the thyroid, one could speculate that bromide administration might be effective in blocking thyroidal uptake of radioactive I in humans. Clearly, more animal research is needed to evaluate this possible therapy. Moreover, the longer term effects of Br on the thyroid and other body tissues would need thorough evaluation.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. H. Baker Animal Models in Nutrition Research J. Nutr., February 1, 2008; 138(2): 391 - 396. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. N. Dilger, S. Toue, T. Kimura, R. Sakai, and D. H. Baker Excess Dietary L-Cysteine, but Not L-Cystine, Is Lethal for Chicks but Not for Rats or Pigs J. Nutr., February 1, 2007; 137(2): 331 - 338. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. R. Augspurger, C. S. Scherer, T. A. Garrow, and D. H. Baker Dietary S-Methylmethionine, a Component of Foods, Has Choline-Sparing Activity in Chickens J. Nutr., July 1, 2005; 135(7): 1712 - 1717. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |