|
|
||||||||
Department of Physiology and Biophysics, Georgetown University, Washington, District of Columbia 20057
1 To whom requests for reprints should be addressed at Department of Physiology & Biophysics, Georgetown University, Box 571460, Washington, DC 20057-1460. E-mail: fughberman{at}aol.com
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Citrus aurantium Seville orange herbal medicine weight-loss products synephrine octopamine bergapten dihydroxybergapten
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Ephedra-free herbal weight-loss preparations have rapidly replaced ephedra products on drugstore shelves. Many of these new products contain Citrus aurantium, which until recently, was a rather obscure medicinal herb. Like ephedra, compounds contained in C. aurantium have adrenergic effects that theoretically might result in appetite suppression and lipolysis, but also might carry the same health risks as ephedra. This paper will address the safety, efficacy, and pharmacology of C. aurantium extracts for weight loss and body composition.
C. aurantium (also called Seville orange, or sour orange) is a small citrus tree, about five meters tall, with scented white flowers. C. aurantium is too sour to be popular for eating, but the ripe fruit is eaten in Iran (2), and in Mexico the fresh fruits are sometimes eaten with salt and chili paste (3). Immature fruits are sometimes pickled and used as a condiment. The peel of C. aurantium is often used in marmalade, and dried peel is used in bouquet garni and for flavoring a Belgian beer called Orange Muscat (4). Essential oil from the dried peel of unripe fruit flavors Curaçao, Cointreau, and Triple Sec. The flowers are used in tea, whereas the essential oil from the flowers, called neroli, is used in perfumes, liqueurs, and orange-flower water, which is used to flavor sweets (4).
The most common use of C. aurantium is medicinal rather than culinary. The dried, entire unripe fruit is used in Asian herbal medicine primarily to treat digestive problems. It is called Zhi shi in Chinese, Kijitsu in Japanese, and Chisil in Korean. Dried peel of the unripe or ripe fruit is also used in Western herbal medicine to stimulate appetite and gastric secretion (in contrast to the recent marketing of C. aurantiumcontaining products as weight-loss aids). It is a common ingredient in "Swedish bitters" and other gastrointestinal remedies (5). The flowers are occasionally used in folk medicine as a mild sedative.
There is thus a history of benign human consumption of C. aurantium fruit, but the culinary or medicinal use of the herb is limited and would not be likely to result in significant daily intake. The use of the herb as a weight-loss aid could result in very different levels of intake and perhaps a different safety profile. Several components of C. aurantium are cause for concern.
| Active Components and Pharmacology |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Structurally, the active components in C. aurantium are closely related to endogenous neurotransmitters and ephedrine (Fig. 1
). Synephrine is structurally similar to epinephrine, and octopamine is similar in structure to norepinephrine (they differ only in the number of hydroxyl groups on the aromatic ring; Ref. 6). Closely related to synephrine is l-m-synephrine (phenylephrine, neosynephrine). Phenylephrine is an alpha adrenoreceptor agonist used in conventional medicine as a nasal decongestant and as a midriatic agent (7). It will not be discussed here because it is not present in C. aurantium.
|
Dopamine beta-hydroxylase converts tyramine into octopamine; this biosynthesis is enhanced by monoamine oxidase inhibition (10). Phenylethanolamine N-methyl transferase catabolizes octopamine into synephrine (9). Synephrine has alpha-adrenergic effects and activates ß-3 (but not ß-1 or ß-2) adrenoreceptors (9). Octopamine appears to be a selective ß-3 adrenoreceptor agonist (10). Both synephrine and octopamine appear to inhibit cAMP production (6).
The functions of endogenous synephrine and octopamine have not been well delineated. Once termed "false neurotransmitters," synephrine, octopamine, and tyramine may in fact be true neurotransmitters (9). These amines may affect platelet-mediated signaling events, and may contribute to the pathophysiology of migraine and other types of headaches (11).
The compound d,l-m-octopamine has an antidipsogenic effect on angiotensin II-induced water intake in rats. The effect is apparently mediated by
-2-adrenoreceptors, because it is blocked by yohimbine (12). Synephrine had antidepressant-like effects in a mouse model utilizing immobility tests, but the effect was not dose-related. No effect was noted at the lowest (0.3 mg/kg) or highest (30 mg/kg) dose, and the effects of 3 mg/kg and 10 mg/kg were similar (13). Alpha-1 adrenoreceptors appear to be involved, because the effects of synephrine were reversed by administration of the
-1 antagonist prazosin. In a later study by the same group, S-(+)-p-synephrine was more effective than R-()-p-synephrine in reducing immobility in the tail suspension test (14).
| Synephrine Content in C. aurantium Products |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It appears from the limited data available that dried fruits, extracts, and commercial C. aurantium products contain significant amounts of synephrine, but octopamine may not be present in sufficient amounts to be of concern.
| Hemodynamic Effects |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Few studies have been performed. In 12 healthy men, synephrine (4mg/min continuous iv infusion) significantly increased systolic and mean arterial pressures, whereas diastolic pressure and heart rate were unchanged (18). Systolic blood pressure increased from a mean of 123 mm Hg to 150 mm Hg (P < 0.005), and mean arterial pressure increased from 91 mm Hg to 100 mm Hg (P < 0.005). Cardiac index increased significantly from 3.6 to 4.6 L/min/ m2 (P < 0.001), whereas left ventricular contractility parameters, assessed echocardiographically, also increased significantly. The authors also reported a drop in total peripheral resistance (although one would expect the opposite action for an alpha agonist).
A weight-loss study of a combination product containing 975 mg C. aurantium extract (6% synephrine alkaloids) found no effect on blood pressure at 6 weeks (19). A crossover, open-label study in 12 normotensive adults tested the cardiovascular effects of C. aurantium juice (17). Eight ounces of juice was administered orally in two doses, 8 hours apart, and the test was repeated with water a week later. It was estimated that subjects consumed approximately 1314 mg of synephrine, approximately comparable to a dose of phenylephrine in an over-the-counter cold preparation. Blood pressure was taken every hour for 5 hours after the second dose of juice. Systolic and diastolic blood pressures, mean arterial pressure, and heart rate were not significantly altered. Oddly, hemodynamic indices were not measured after the initial dose of C. aurantium juice. The omission of blood pressure measurements after the initial dose of juice considerably limits the interpretation of this study.
A Chinese study reported that 50 children with infective shock were treated with a combination of synephrine and N-methyltyrosamine (in a 1:1 ratio; doses ranged from 1.66 to 24.0 mg/kg; Ref. 20). The inexplicable claim that "curative effects were seen in 48 cases" is contradicted by the next sentence, which states that 10 patients died. This does not appear to be a reliable study. In the same report, a beneficial effect of a C. aurantium extract or a synthetic combination of synephrine and N-methyltyrosamine (each 4 mg/kg/hr iv) was claimed on an endotoxin-induced shock model in dogs (20). Another study of a combination product containing synephrine and N-methyltyramine extracted from C. aurantium as well as saponins from ginseng (Panax spp) found similar effects on blood pressure and contractility in both normal dogs and dogs in endotoxic shock (21).
Effects of C. aurantium have also been studied in a rat model in which the hepatic portal vein was partially ligated to produce portal hypertension. Infusion of either a preparation made from a crude aqueous extract of C. aurantium (containing 12.5 mg synephrine/g extract), infused at 1.25, 2.5, or 5.0 mg/kg, or pure synephrine (infused at 0.095, 0.19, or 0.38 mg/kg/min) reduced portal pressure both in rats with surgically induced portal hypertension and sham-treated rats. The C. aurantium extract had a significantly greater effect in the portal hypertension model (22). In this model, the efficacy of vasoconstrictors to reduce portal pressure can probably be attributed to their constrictive actions in the splanchnic arterial circulation, and to the greater efficacy of C. aurantium extract in the portal hypertensives compared with sham-operated rats, and is consistent with a predominantly arterial, as opposed to venous, constrictive action of the extract.
Systemically, both the C. aurantium extract and synephrine elevated arterial blood pressure, as expected. In vitro, C. aurantium extract induced greater contraction of the aorta and mesenteric artery than the portal vein, whereas synephrine caused contraction of the aorta but was largely ineffective in the portal vein and mesenteric artery. Thus, C. aurantium extract appears to constrict arterial vessels and would therefore reduce splanchnic blood flow into the portal circulation. In addition, the effects of C. aurantium and synephrine differ to some degree, suggesting that the hemodynamic effects of C. aurantium are not entirely due to synephrine (22).
An 8-day study in two models of portal hypertensive rats (portal vein ligation and bile duct ligation) found that, compared with vehicle control, synephrine (1 mg/kg/12 hours by gavage) significantly reduced portal venous pressure and, in general, improved many of the hemodynamic alterations associated with the portal hypertension and systemic and splanchnic hyperemic states that characterize these models (23). The effects of synephrine in ameliorating portal hypertension were moderate, and less than those of propranolol (30 mg/kg/day) or octreotide (100 µg/kg/12 hrs).
In summary, synephrine appears to increase blood pressure in humans, rats, and dogs, but C. aurantium preparations may have hemodynamic effects that differ from those of synephrine. A pharmacokinetic study suggests no acute hemodynamic effect of C. aurantium juice in humans at the doses tested, and a combination product containing C. aurantium extract did not affect blood pressure at 6 weeks. In portal hypertensive rats, C. aurantium extract increased systemic blood pressure and affected portal hypertension in a manner consistent with arterial constriction. Available data are sparse and not entirely consistent. There are insufficient data to draw definitive conclusions about the hemodynamic effects of C. aurantium as compared with synephrine, and more studies are needed in this area.
| Effects on Weight Loss and Lipolysis |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The treatment group lost 2.9% of fat, whereas there was no significant change in the placebo or control groups. No significant changes were seen in any group in a Profile of Mood States Questionnaire, blood lipids, blood pressure, heart rate, electrocardiogram, serum chemistries, or urinalyses. The treated group experienced a significant increase in basal metabolic rate, whereas the placebo group experienced a significant decrease in basal metabolic rate. There was no change in the untreated control group. No side effects were reported.
Assuming that the 3% hypericum actually means 0.3% hypericin, the dose of St. Johns wort (Hypericum perforatum) in this particular product would be a therapeutic antidepressant dose. There is no clinical evidence that St. Johns wort helps weight loss, but depression can certainly predispose to overeating.
This product contains a generous amount of caffeine, the equivalent of about 4 cups of coffee or 10 cups of tea. Caffeine has a thermogenic effect, and this effect is synergistic with other sympathomimetic agents. Even 100 mg caffeine has a thermogenic effect lasting 12 hrs, and dosages >600 mg/day increase 24-hr energy expenditure under respiratory chamber conditions (24).
Beta-3 adrenoreceptor agonists do have lipolytic effects in the fat cells of rats, hamsters, and dogs, but they are much less active in human fat cells. Octopamine was more potent than synephrine (but far less potent than norepinephrine) for stimulating lipolysis in adipocytes from rats, hamsters, or dogs; however, the effect was not significant in fat cells from guinea pigs or humans (10). Octopamine was fully lipolytic in adipocytes from the garden dormouse and Siberian hamster (25).
In rat cells, activation of lipolysis by octopamine was found to be a specific ß-3 adrenergic effect, and was reversible by administration of a ß-3 adrenoreceptor antagonist (ß-1 and ß-2 receptors did not appear to be activated; Ref. 10). Human fat cells respond only to activation of ß-1 or ß-2 receptors (although low levels of ß-3 adrenergic receptors are also expressed). Only high concentrations of synephrine (0.11 mM) significantly stimulated lipolysis in the fat cells of humans, hamsters, and guinea pigs, and the effect was not significant in rats (10).
In summary, the only published trial of a C. aurantiumcontaining weight-loss product found that the product was not superior to placebo for weight loss. There is no evidence that synephrine and octopamine in levels that would be found in weight-loss products would have any lipolytic effect on human adipocytes.
| Adverse Effects and Drug Interactions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
C. aurantium, grapefruit (C. paradisi), and pomelo (C. maximi) contain several flavonoids that affect drug metabolism, including 6',7'-dihydroxybergamottin, which is used to selectively block intestinal cytochrome P450 isoenzyme CYP3A4 in bioavailability studies. C. aurantium, but not grapefruit, also contains a furocoumarin, bergapten, that also inhibits CYP3A4 in cultured intestinal epithelial cells, but the effect is weaker than that of 6',7'-dihydroxybergamottin (27).
CYP3A4 metabolizes more than a quarter of pharmaceuticals, and grapefruit juice increases blood levels of many drugs (28). C. aurantium, predictably, also increases drug levels, and because it contains bergapten as well as 6',7'-dihydroxybergamottin, may have an even stronger effect than grapefruit juice.
A recent clinical pharmacokinetics study found that C. aurantium juice, but not grapefruit juice, significantly increased plasma levels of concurrently administered indinavir (29). Another clinical study found that C. aurantium juice affected felodipine pharmacokinetics similarly to grapefruit juice, increasing maximum concentration and AUC (area under the concentration-time curve) without affecting terminal elimination half-life (27). And a third pharmacokinetics study found that both C. aurantium juice and grapefruit juice increased the bioavailability of dextromethorphan (30).
The only clinical study that found no effect of C. aurantium compared the effects of grapefruit juice and C. aurantium juice on the pharmacokinetics of cyclosporine. Although C. aurantium reduced enterocyte concentration of CYP3A4 by 40%, only grapefruit juice affected cyclosporine disposition (31). This can be explained by the fact that bioavailability of cyclosporine is affected by P-glycoprotein (a membrane-localized drug transporter) as well as CYP3A4, and grapefruit, but not C. aurantium, is known to affect P-glycoprotein. Also, species differences may affect results. In swine, coadministration of a C. aurantium decoction doubled the AUC and significantly increased the Cmax of cyclosporine, and several animals manifested signs of cyclosporine toxicity (32).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Potential health risks exist. The documented effects of synephrine on blood pressure would be expected to increase the risk of cardiovascular events, especially in those with preexisting cardiovascular disease. The single clinical study of C. aurantium juice that showed no effect on hemodynamics should not be reassuring for several reasons. First, herbal products contain not only fruit, but also rind, which is much higher in synephrine than the fruit. Second, the effect of initial dosing with the juice was inexplicably not determined, and the lack of effect of the second dose may reflect tolerance. Finally, the study was conducted in normotensive adults, who may react differently to vasopressors than hypertensive adults. Hypertension is common among overweight individuals, the population targeted for promotion of weight-loss products.
C. aurantium juice is a potent inhibitor of CYP3A4 and would be expected to increase the blood level of many drugs. This could potentially increase the toxicity of drugs, including warfarin, that have a narrow therapeutic window.
Some herbal weight-loss products combine C. aurantium and St. Johns wort (H. perforatum). While C. aurantium inhibits CYP3A4, St. Johns wort induces CYP3A4 as well as the drug transporter P-glycoprotein. St. Johns wort reduces levels of many drugs, including digoxin, tricyclic antidepressants, phenprocoumon (a warfarin-type anticoagulant not used therapeutically in the United States), and cyclosporine (33). A product containing both C. aurantium and St. Johns wort would be expected to have unpredictable interactions with drugs.
An argument may be made that C. aurantium has been used for thousands of years in traditional Chinese medicine and that such use should be an indirect marker of safety. The same argument has been used for ephedra. Ephedra has been used for asthma and other respiratory problems, and C. aurantium has been used as an expectorant or for digestive problems. However, neither ephedra nor C. aurantium has been used traditionally for weight loss.
What we do know about ephedra should warn us about C. aurantium. The traditional use of ephedra for specific indications and for short periods of time does not appear to be dangerous. Virtually all adverse effects associated with ephedra have been observed with ephedra-containing products promoted for weight loss, exercise enhancement, energy enhancement, or recreational use. None of these uses are traditional indications, and all utilize doses meant to speed metabolism.
C. aurantium, as well, is traditionally used in crude form, for short periods of time, and for specific indications. Weight loss is not a traditional indication. Additionally, the use of concentrated extracts, perhaps combined with other sympathomimetic herbs or drugs, over extended periods of time, has no precedent in traditional use. Given what we know about the cardiovascular effects of synephrine, modern usage in weight-loss products should not be presumed to be safe.
There is some evidence that C. aurantium extracts have different effects than pure synephrine, but these differences must be explored in appropriately designed studies. It is not unusual for crude herb extracts to have very different effects than isolated constituents. However, data available to date are insufficient to support safety claims of C. aurantium extracts.
Consumers may find it difficult to determine whether or not a product contains C. aurantium, because the botanical name may not appear on the label. Citrus oils are considered by the Food and Drug Administration to be Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) and are commonly used as food flavorings and additives. Manufacturers are not required to state the amount present nor the botanical name of citrus oils, and the only clue on some labels that essential oils are present may be the term "natural flavoring." Products containing synephrine or octopamine should at least be labeled with the amount. This could help determine whether manufacturers are "spiking" products with higher levels of synephrine or octopamine than would normally be found in C. aurantium.
Unless and until the short- and long-term safety and efficacy of C. aurantium extracts are established, consumers should be advised to avoid C. aurantiumcontaining weight-loss products, which may have adverse effects on hemodynamics and may interact with many drugs. While the limited literature available provides a basis for concern, basic testing on safety and efficacy has not been performed, and both basic and clinical research into the physiological and pathological effects of C. aurantium and its active components should be encouraged.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2A-adrenoceptor. Br J Pharmacol 122:191198, 1997.[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. A. Gange, C. Madias, E. M. Felix-Getzik, A. R. Weintraub, and N. A. M. Estes III Variant Angina Associated With Bitter Orange in a Dietary Supplement Mayo Clin. Proc., April 1, 2006; 81(4): 545 - 548. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. T Bui, D. T Nguyen, and P. J Ambrose Blood Pressure and Heart Rate Effects Following a Single Dose of Bitter Orange Ann. Pharmacother., January 1, 2006; 40(1): 53 - 57. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. C. Bouchard, M. A. Howland, H. A. Greller, R. S. Hoffman, and L. S. Nelson Ischemic Stroke Associated With Use of an Ephedra-Free Dietary Supplement Containing Synephrine Mayo Clin. Proc., April 1, 2005; 80(4): 541 - 545. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |